Thunderbird Photo

A real thunderbird?

This is one of those matters in Cryptozoology that shall be forever unsolvable at this point. The situation is that once upon a time there was supposed to be a photograph which had been circulated in the late 1950s or early 1960s, which was seen casually by several persons someplace or another. and then at one point in time, Cryptozoologist Ivan T. Sanderson found that the only copy he had, in form of a photostat from some unspecified earlier publication, had been lost while out on loan to some researchers. Naturally enough, Sanderson wanted to get another copy of it as a replacement. And then something happened (perhaps baffling but perhaps not): nobody seemed to be able to find another copy of the photo or even identify where it had originally come from. To quote an internet source on the subject:

…The story of the Thunderbird was relegated to the ranks of creatures like the “jackalope” until 1963, when the story was revived. In the May 1963 issue of Saga, a men’s magazine of the day, writer Jack Pearl recounted the story of the Tombstone Thunderbird, along with some large bird sightings of the early 1960’s. Not only did he tell the story though, he went one step further and claimed that the Tombstone Epitaph had, in 1886, “published a photograph of a huge bird nailed to a wall. The newspaper said that it had been shot by two prospectors and hauled into town by wagon. Lined up in front of the bird were six grown men with their arms outstretched, fingertip to fingertip. The creature measured about 36 feet from wingtip to wingtip.”

While this is a different variation of the story (and size of the creature), it seems to be referring to the same incident. Was this nothing more than a mythic legend of the west, or was there something to the story after all?

In the September 1963 issue of Fate magazine, a correspondent to the magazine named H.M Cranmer would state that not only was the story true, but the photo was published and had appeared in newspapers all over America. And Cranmer would not be the only one who remembered the photo. Eminent researcher Ivan T. Sanderson also remembered seeing the photo and in fact, even claimed to have once had a photostat of it that he loaned to two associates, who lost it. The editors of Fate even came to believe that they may have published the photo in an earlier issue of the magazine but a search through back issues failed to reveal it. Meanwhile, the original Epitaph story, which again mentions no photograph, was revived in a 1969 issue of Old West, further confusing the issue as to whether the photo was real or not.

The Epitaph however stated that it did not exist, or if it did, it had not been in their newspaper. Responding to numerous inquiries, employees of the paper started a thorough search of back issues and files. They could find no such photo and even an extended search of other Arizona and California newspapers of the period produced no results. A number of articles that appeared in Pursuit, the journal for the Society for the Investigation of the Unexplained prompted a memory from W. Ritchie Benedict, who recalled seeing Ivan T. Sanderson himself display a copy[photostat-DD] of the photo on a Canadian television show “The Pierre Benton Show”. Unfortunately though, no copies of the show have ever been found.

So, is the photo real? And if not, then why do so many of us with an interest in the unusual claim to remember seeing it? Who knows? In the late 1990’s, author John Keel insisted that “I know I saw it! And not only that – I compared notes with a lot of other people who saw it.” Like many of us, Keel believes that he saw it in one of the men’s magazines (like Saga or True) that were so popular in the 1960’s. Most of these magazines dealt with amazing subject matter like Bigfoot, ghosts and more. Keel also remembers the photo in the same way that most of us do – with men wearing cowboy clothing and the bird looking like a pterodactyl or some prehistoric, winged creature. [John Keel even said specifically that the creature did not look like aarge vulture with a hooked beak, as Sanderson’s explanation had it. Keel said it had a long and pointed beak like a Pteranodon. This is quoted in such books as Jerome Clark’s Unexplained!-DD]

Interestingly, a reprint of the original article that appeared in Old West magazine caused a reader to remember another strange incident. He wrote to the magazine in the summer of 1970 and gave a firsthand account of a separate flying monster incident that also occurred near Tombstone. The writer had met two cowboys who told about seeing a similar creature around 1890, although they had shot at and chased the creature until their horses refused to go any further. This giant bird was not killed, brought to town or photographed. In fact, except for the fact that it was not shot down, their account sounds much closer to Bell’s original report.

During the 1990’s, the search for the “Thunderbird Photo” reached a point of obsession for those interested in the subject. A discussion of the matter stretched over several issues of Mark Chorvinsky’s Strange magazine and readers who believed they had seen the photo cited sources that ranged from old books, to Western photograph collections, men’s magazines, National Geographic and beyond. As for myself, I combed through literally hundreds of issues of dusty copies of True and Saga but could find nothing more than the previously mentioned article by Jack Pearl. If the photo exists, I certainly don’t have it in my own collection.

So, how do we explain this weird phenomena of a photograph that so many remember seeing and yet no one can seem to find? Author Mark Hall believes that the description of the photo creates such a vivid image in the mind that many people who have a knowledge and an interest in curious and eclectic things begin to think the photo is familiar. It literally creates a “shared memory” of something that does not exist. We think we have seen it, but we actually have not.

To be honest, I can’t say for sure if I agree with this or not. I can certainly see the possibility of a “memory” like this that we have created from inside of our own overcrowded minds, but then again, what if the photo does exist and it’s out there, just waiting to be discovered in some dusty garage, overflowing file cabinet or musty basement. I, for one, haven’t given up quite yet – and I have a feeling that I am not the only one who is still out there looking.

But are thunderbirds and mysterious flying creatures actually real? Do they fill the skies of anything other than our imaginations? If not, then what have so many people seen over the years? At this point, such creatures remain a mystery but one thing is sure, the sightings have continued over the years and occasionally an unusual report still trickles in from somewhere across America. So keep that in mind the next time that you are standing in an open field and a large, dark shadow suddenly fills the sky overhead. Was that just a cloud passing in front of the sun – or something else??

Late in the 1990s while working at IUPUI I had found a copy of a photo which I took to be the original of the “Lost” thiunderbird photo from a collection of photos purporting to represent surviving Pterosaurs on a Creationist website. It was in fact the same photo which Loren Coleman illustrates first in a Cryptomundo posting in March 2006

At this point, Coleman quoted another researcher who had published the photo without comment or caption. At the time, Coleman did not know me and I did not know the other fellow (the link Coleman posted at Cryptomundo for this person’s blog has long since gone dead) So, Later in 2006, I mentioned casually to Coleman that I thought I had a copy of the original Thunderbird photo. Not knowing about the other fellow, I sent Coleman another copy of the same photo. I gather Coleman did not take it well, for he never got back to me on the matter.

So WHY did I choose that anonymously-submitted example from the 1990s? Two things in particular: the first is that the bird did NOT match the usual idea of what the “Thunderbird” in the photo was supposed to look like, BUT it matched John Keel’s description specifically and exactly. And the second reason is that This copy is not a photograph, it is a photostat, as Sanderson’s copy was supposed to have been.

So WHY was everyone going around looking for a photo that showed a bird nailed to a barn with six cowboys standing under it with fingertips touchig to mark six fathoms? Because that was the remaining published description of the photo from Saga magazine. And WHY was nobody able to find the photo again? My guess was that the description was wrong: near enough right to ring a bell with people who had seen the montage but not exact enough that the original could be recognised again by going on the published description.

My solution as far back as the period the SITU was still up and active, was that the photograph had been a montage and could possibly have come in more than one variation: indeed some accounts mention more than one photo. Here is a copy of another reconstruction of what the photo was supposed to look like taken from one of the Cryptozoological discussion boards, original without credit but I would guess from Deviant Art. And please note it does NOT match the published description from Saga either:

Compare to the version at the top. The bird could be mistakenly remembered as being in the upside-down position when it was actually rightside up and people were remembering THAT photo; or else it is also possible that an alternate montage pasted on the figure of the bird upside down as well.

Here is another remembrance, with the witness this time inverting the bird to the rightside-up version as better representing what the witness remembered:

In a letter to then-SITU President Bob Warth during the early 1990s I spoke of my belief that the photograph had been a montage and that I had seen what I thought was the same photo without the bird. I had been through the SITU’s files about the missing photograph at that point and I deduced that this following photograph of the death of outlaw John Sontag (1893) had been the BASE Photograph one or more montages had been built up on:

Another clever internet viewer later came to the same conclusion.

As to where or when the original montage could have been made, it COULD have been made anytime after 1893: my guess is sometime in the early 20th century and possibly as an April Fool’s gag or possibly a souvenir postcard coming out of Tombstone Arizona or anywhere else in the Southwest. Possibly not the only variation of the idea in circulation, either. BUT The version shown at the top of this page is most likely the version in the possession of Ivan Sanderson and remembered by John Keel, because of the specific reasons given above.

About Admin

Since my very first sighting of a pretty large, silent and very bizarre object up in the sky (which I knew for sure was not a plane etc.), and that was around the age of 15, I started down the path of becoming very interested and then apart of paranormal phenomenon and doing investigations when I could. There had been and still is, many paranormal related events that have happened to me. This blog is my launching point to share it all. Other than all that, I'm just a guy who has been geeking it out with computers since 1986...the good old days when computers had character! I am also a guitar player for more than 20 years who has always been into and plays metal. 1980s, early 90's style metal. Aside from all that, I am very much into amateur radio (shortwave, HAM radio and so on). There's a lot more that I'm interested in, in life of course. I'm a person who gets into a pretty mixed bag of interesting things in life!


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Have a news tip?

Email your news tips to be posted in the Para News section.

Report your sightings

Have an experience, encounter or a sighting with the paranormal, such as ghosts, a UFO sighting, cryptid sightings etc., you'd like to share? Send in your true story or picture(s) of a paranormal experience to be included in the True stories section.

Contact the webmaster:

Questions, suggestions or comments? Drop me an email and I'll get back to you as soon as I can. Email the webmaster.

Cryptid News!

Cryptid News

Site Calender

May 2011
« Apr   Jun »

RSS Paranormal Phenomena

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Crypto News

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Para Videos

RSS Podcasts

  • The Slenderman Mysteries - Paranormal Podcast 526 March 15, 2018
    Has the Slenderman evolved from an innocent meme taken way too far in a tragic crime to something that has subsequently manifested itself? Nick Redfern joins us to discuss this controversial theory. You can find Nick's book on the subject on Amazon: The Slenderman Mysteries: An Internet Urban Legend Comes to Life In part two, Matty Blake joins us to tal […]
  • Discussing Life After Life with Dr Raymond Moody - Paranormal Podcast 525 March 7, 2018
    Near Death Experience. We talk to the man who invented the phrase, Dr. Raymond Moody, on this edition of The Paranormal Podcast. We discuss his thoughts on what happens after we die, how he got into this work and much more. It was an honor to speak to this legend. You can find his books at Dr. Raymond Moody Page at Thanks Dr. Moody! -G […]
  • New England Legends - The Paranormal Podcast 524 February 27, 2018
    The Paranormal Renaissance Man himself, Jeff Belanger joins us to talk about creepy New England Legends. You can find his show HERE Thanks Jeff!
  • Black Eyed Kids Revisited - Paranormal Podcast 523 February 22, 2018
    The phenomena of "Black Eyed Kids" is one of the most terrifying ever recorded. The world's foremost researcher on the subject, David Weatherly, joins us to discuss them on this week's Paranormal Podcast. We also talk about the home of Mothman -- Point Pleasant, West Virginia. You can find David's updated edition of his book on Black […]
  • Conspiracies and Science in Ghosthunting - Paranormal Podcast 522 February 13, 2018
    Richard Syrett of Coast To Coast AM fame joins us on The Paranormal Podcast to talk about conspiracies, the paranormal and his new podcast. In part two, Sharon Hill talks to us about the use or misuse of science in ghosthunting. You can find Richard's new podcast on Apple Podcasts, wherever fine podcasts are heard or at his website at conspiracy-unlimit […]
  • Sister of Darkness - Paranormal Podcast 521 February 6, 2018
    A modern exorcist, RH Stavis, is our guest on this edition of The Paranormal Podcast. In part two, Keith J. Scales tells us all about the most haunted hotel in America. You can find their books at Sister of Darkness: The Chronicles of a Modern Exorcist House of a Hundred Rooms: Tales the Ghost Tour Guides Do Not Tell Thanks RH & Keith! --- No […]
  • UFOs: Reframing The Debate - Paranormal Podcast 520 January 31, 2018
    Maybe we've been looking at the UFO question in the wrong way. That is the premise behind our guest's latest book. Robbie Graham says we need to reframe the debate. You'll find Robbie's book at Amazon: UFOs: Reframing the Debate In part two, we visit with author and UFO experiencer Dr. Robert Jacobs. A mentor and friend, I think you' […]
  • Tarot and Occult Detectives - Paranormal Podcast 519 January 24, 2018
    Janet Boyer joins us on The Paranormal Podcast to discuss how we can use the tarot impact our lives. In part two, Judika Illes tells us all about "occult detectives." This was a fun show, I hope you enjoy it! You can find Janet & Judika's books at Affect Your Reality With Tarot Cards The Weiser Book of Occult Detectives: 13 Sto […]
  • Are There Ancient ETs In The Bible - Paranormal Podcast 518 January 18, 2018
    Are ancient aliens depicted in the Bible? Author Xaviant Haze says the answer is yes! We talk about a possible Vatican coverup and more on this edition of The Paranormal Podcast. In part two, British UFO researcher and author Philip Mantle and I have a wide ranging discussions of UFOs including the Rendlesham Forest incident and the famous Pascagoula case in […]
  • Moon Magic - Paranormal Podcast 517 January 9, 2018
    Diane Ahlquist joins us on The Paranormal Podcast to discuss how we can harness the magical properties of the moon in our lives. In part two, Natalie Zaman talks to us about conjuring and coloring...a unique combination. You can find their books on Moon Magic: Your Complete Guide to Harnessing the Mystical Energy of the Moon Color and Conjure: Ri […]

RSS Hot Topics!

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Most Popular

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Unexplained

  • Weird winged wonders March 8, 2018
    Sean Casteel: Sean Casteel takes a look at cases of strange flying creatures. Who among us hasn't wished to spread their wings and fly? To cease to be earthbound and soar to the heavens? But perhaps, in real-world terms, a person with wings might not...
  • February, the month of the Hierophant February 6, 2018
    Kathleen Meadows: Kathleen Meadows talks about love, Valentine's Day and the Hierophant. I was going to launch into Happy Valentine's Day and then changed my mind. I had a complete first draft written, using the tarot Lover's card to plant the theme – until I ...
  • Out of our minds: are UFOs thought-forms? January 27, 2018
    Edward Crabtree: Are UFOs physical or psychological in nature ? The Martians had a chat with Gary Wilcox on 25th of April 54 years ago. At around 10 A.M in the morning in Newark Valley in New York State, the farmer noticed a cigar shaped craft suspended over o...
  • Project Magnet 'exposed' December 31, 2017
    Sean Casteel: A look at the life and work of Canadian radio engineer Wilbert Smith. Though it is a little known fact, the truth is that certain individuals with ties to the Canadian government have secretly been promoting the idea that UFOs are operating in...
  • Close encounters today: a global UFO update December 18, 2017
    Joe Posner: A look at the current state of the UFO phenomenon. Based on recent data collected, as you read this, a close encounter could very well be happening somewhere in the world. The number of experiencers ranges from a single witness to hundreds. So...
  • Journey to the Akashic Records December 1, 2017
    Rob MacGregor: A detailed look at the out-of-body experiences of Wesley Meeks. He's a retired cop from Texas who kept a secret from his fellow officers for decades. Wesley Meeks has the ability to travel out of his body, and his journeys have taken him liter...
  • Physics, the Bible and the parting of the Red Sea November 2, 2017
    Sean Casteel: Sean Casteel on Reverend Barry Downing. Science and religion could end up complementing each other. New – more "radical" – trends in physics point to the existence of parallel universes and other dimensions which could assist in explaining man...
  • The real aliens: a survey of 'praying mantis' entity reports October 12, 2017
    Edward Crabtree: Edward Crabtree reports. Back in 1967 a child called Paul Nelson took a holiday with his parents and another male friend in Catalina Island off the coast of California. His buddy and he had bought some comic books and they seated themselves in...
  • Washingtonople: The secret history of America's capital: Part 3 September 25, 2017
    Conrad Yeats: From 'Raising Atlantis'. If indeed the Giza necropolis has been recreated on the banks of the Potomac in the form of America’s National Mall, then one final, vital landmark must still be discussed: The Sphynx, which anchors the east end of the...
  • Words as symbols September 11, 2017
    Kathleen Meadows: Kathleen Meadows explores the power of both the spoken and written word. We sometimes forget that when we're using words, we are passing symbols back and forth. This means we must make assumptions like for example, that we agree upon the meani...

RSS What’s Hot

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Webmasters Pick!

More and more UFO sightings are being captured on video and more these days. Are we about to be apart of an actual contact event? Do you believe we are really being watched? Watch this DVD & you will not think the same way again!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 34 other followers

Add to Technorati Favorites Dailygalaxy_150x35_026
Paranormal Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Join My Community at MyBloglog!
Paranormal Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory

Subscribe & Share Here

Fair Use Notice

This site may or may not contain copyrighted material the use of which may not be specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific, social justice, and religious issues, etc., pertaining to paranormal issues. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
%d bloggers like this: